Frequently, when Capillary has been engaged to design or enhance a loyalty program, one opportunity we see consistently rising to the top for evaluation is a paid subscription tier. Senior marketing leaders and the C-Suite often see it as a “no-brainer” – adding a new revenue stream while providing their best customers with extra perks that cement loyalty. While a well-reasoned, thoughtfully designed and executed subscription program or tier can deliver on both counts, they aren’t necessarily the right strategy for every organization. So when might it make sense to subscribe to the idea (or at least test) of a paid subscription model? If the following 3 situations likely apply to you, then it may be a great opportunity to explore further:
Target Customers Are Highly Likely to Enroll and Engage: As with any program, it all starts with a program design that your target customers embrace. The wrinkle here is that you are asking them to pay for the access, so the benefits you offer have to be compelling and exclusive (even vs. your top elite tier(s)). Case in point: Amazon Prime started with free shipping, added video, music, Prime Days and more.
Adding the Subscription Option Enhances Elite Customer Loyalty: Or at a minimum, “does no harm” to relationships forged with your top elite members and/or customers who have earned their elevated perks by demonstrating their loyalty. We typically find that subscription members are sourced from all customer levels – non-members, base and elite; however, the bulk of enrollments come from your highest spending/most profitable customers. This underscores the strategic approach in designing the program elements to appeal to top customers, providing them with high perceived value perks unavailable at their current level.
The Financials Are Solid: In designing any program, Capillary grounds our recommendations with extensive voice of customer research (typically online surveys of target customers) AND rigorous financial decision modelling of program financial contribution and ROI. With paid subscription programs/tiers, these 2 foundational efforts are even more critical. Regardless of who designs your program, it’s critical to get your customers’ relative assessments on alternative subscription structures, perks and most importantly, fee sensitivity. What are the trade-offs in enrollment and potential incremental spend at alternative subscription price points? What are projected enrollments, revenues, lift in spend/profits, and incremental expenses? How do these financial contributions differ assuming alternative growth, enrollment, and engagement scenarios?
These are just the top 3 considerations. Your industry may have additional contributing factors which sway the decision one way or the other. If you’re considering adding a subscription program, or if it’s been a while since you’ve done anything new with your current program, or if you’re considering a new program, Capillary has a team of experienced consultants who can lend their decades of experience designing leading B2B, B2C and B2E programs across multiple industries and countries.
About the Author
Randy Hernandez
Vice President, Strategy, Capillary Technologies
Randy has designed loyalty solutions for global companies across multiple verticals including the retail, consumer packaged goods, dining, entertainment, and financial services industries. Prior to joining Brierley in 2017, he was CMO for several fintech firms. With over 25 years of marketing experience, Randy has held progressively senior digital, direct, loyalty, and brand management roles serving leading firms in the financial services, airline, and consumer packaged goods industries.
Share
Randy has designed loyalty solutions for global companies across multiple verticals including the retail, consumer packaged goods, dining, entertainment, and financial services industries. Prior to joining Brierley in 2017, he was CMO for several fintech firms. With over 25 years of marketing experience, Randy has held progressively senior digital, direct, loyalty, and brand management roles serving leading firms in the financial services, airline, and consumer packaged goods industries.